Transcript 0:00 [gentle music] Welcome to Act Three, the podcast where we explore how to thoughtfully shape the rest of our lives. I'm your host, Kara Gray. 0:10 This podcast is sponsored by Good Morning Freedom, my retirement coaching service where I help executives and professionals plan their act three. For more information, stay tuned until the end. 0:23 Today, I welcome Chris Farrell to the podcast. Chris is Senior Economics contributor at Minnesota Public Radio and Marketplace, American Public Media's nationally syndicated public radio business and economic programs. 0:37 He is a columnist for MarketWatch, PBS Next Avenue, and the Minneapolis Star Tribune. Among his most recent books are The New Frugality, Unretirement, and Purpose and a Paycheck. Welcome, Chris, to Act Three. 0:55 Oh, well, thank you for having me. Sure. 0:58 You have written a great deal in the space of employment, money, and purpose with regards to older individuals, and I know your thoughts and perspectives are gonna be incredibly valuable for my listeners, so I'm very excited for this conversation. 1:14 Let's start with your book, Unretirement, 'cause that is what caught my eye the most when I found you for this interview. [laughing] And you talk about how re-retirement is being redefined. 1:28 Now, I am curious what inspired you to explore this theme, and this book was published back in two thousand and fourteen. 1:35 What inspired you to explore this theme, and what are the most surprising findings you've uncovered about modern retirement? 1:43 So even going, so it was twenty fourteen, so I probably started the work, what, say twenty twelve, twenty eleven. But, uh, there were two strands to my journalistic career, and one strand has been personal finance. 1:58 And if you think about personal finance over the past three decades, the theme has been baby boomers or the aging population haven't saved enough for their elder years, and their standard of living is going to fall dramatically. 2:12 And then if you think about the other strand of my journalistic career, which has been economics, there's been this underlying pessimism with the demographics of aging, that the underlying dynamism of the U.S. 2:23 economy is going to disappear because we're gonna have, uh, too few young workers supporting too many dependent elderly. 2:32 So when you looked at the aging of the population, it was a story of gloom and doom with all kinds of variations to it, but that was the core. And I just started wondering, you know, is this right? 2:44 Is, you know, markets adjust. Is this... What, what's going on here? And I started doing research, and it turns out there was a lot of research scattered around the world in Europe and Asia, here in the U.S. 2:55 that told a very different story with increased life expectancy, better education, better health. And to be clear, this isn't true for everybody, right? Yeah. But it is true for a segment of the population. 3:09 And what retirement was becoming less full-time leisure and more about, "What do I wanna do next?" Yes. And interrupt at any point. 3:21 Just one other subtheme that, that sort of was, was, was running throughout it is we also have a retirement savings system, and system is, is really, uh, almost the wrong word. We have this patchwork quilt. Yeah. 3:35 And Social Security doesn't replace enough income. And then if you think about half of private sector workers don't have access to an employer-sponsored retirement savings plan at work. 3:46 And all the evidence is, if you have retirement savings, it's because your employer offers you a plan. You may not have much, but you do have some retirement savings. And so 3:56 the need for people to continue to earn an income, that need to pay the bills, but at the same time, you know, work is a community. 4:05 Uh, work can provide that need that we all have to be useful, to exercise our skills over a lifetime. So there was just sort of a rethinking about what is, is the good life in the third act. Yeah. 4:22 And so that book, uh, you know, was published in two thousand and fourteen. What changes have you seen or witnessed since, you know, in the last ten years on the same subject? So I think there's been a lot of changes. 4:37 So that book was called Unretirement because there was this sort of, you know, how do we... What word do we use? I mean, retire is the word that we all use. 4:46 Even people who are still working will say, "I'm retired," because they've retired from their, their primary career- Right... but they're continuing to work doing something else. 4:53 They use that word retire, but retire has this association with full-time leisure. You know, if you wanna be, make it a character, it's, you know, you're on the golf course or you're on the, on the patio barbecuing. 5:05 And so unretirement, uh, was the sort of term that, that came up with. It was very popular in Britain, by the way. Unretirement- Hmm... it was not that popular term here in the U.S.- Okay... 5:15 but it was very, uh, it was used a lot in Britain. And it sort of captured a moment, it captured a trend, again, particularly for people who, um, had some retirement savings, had a career. 5:29 Now, most careers, there are ups and downs, spells of unemployment, you get disappointed. 5:34 But, you know, overall, had a career that provided them with benefits, with health insurance, uh, uh, retirement savings, own their own home, and you're living longer. And so again, it was unretiring. 5:48 You may wanna say goodbye to your colleagues for the last time. "Goodbye. I wanna-- I'm doing something else," right? [laughs] You can do that. You can do that. But you may wanna be doing something. 5:58 And what I've noticed is that this is becoming much morePart of the overall conversation. Now, in Washington DC, this conversation doesn't exist. In most state capitals, this conversation doesn't exist. 6:10 They still wanna talk about, uh, they still wanna go from you're sixty years old to ninety in one year. So- Yeah... 6:18 it's largely a conversation about the frail, dependent, elderly, uh, you know, on the walker, in the wheelchair. That's still the conversation, but when you go into the workplace, it's a very different conversation. 6:31 And so this is a true grassroots movement, and it's an ecosystem, and it's growing, and there's more and more people involved. And the thing about it is there is no right answer. 6:42 There is nothing wrong, absolutely nothing wrong with saying, "I'm retired and I'm not going to ever work again, and I'm going to the beach," or whatever it is you're going to do. Fine, that's wonderful. 6:53 But there's also other people who want to continue to work, use their skills, be part of a community. 7:01 And there, you know, you have to say, "Well, okay, so age discrimination is wrong and we need to combat age discrimination. We need to create more opportunities for, uh, people to shift their careers. 7:14 We need to get senior management to wake up. Stop saying that you can't find the qualified workers that you need. They're there. They're fifty-five years and older. They're there. 7:23 Look for them, reach out to them, hire them." 7:26 So it provides a different dynamic when you're thinking about public policy, but it also provides a different dynamic when you're just thinking about your individual circumstances. Yeah. Um, 7:39 I like that you said that it was grassroots because I, yeah, like this conversation isn't happening at the highest levels yet, or at least this message isn't happening, and I, I, I, I worry about that. 7:51 Um, as people do want to continue working, maybe in a different capacity, maybe in their third act, maybe in a field that they're more passionate about than how they earned money to take care of their family over the years. 8:03 I do know that ageism is super real. Yeah. And I am interested in your thoughts on how, how we can change that narrative. 8:14 Or are employers just gonna be forced to keep, um, you know, to hire older employees as time goes on just because of the need? Well, you know, 8:25 it's hard to, to, to, to, to say where we are right now, but when the book came out in twenty fourteen to where we are now in twenty twenty-four, there has been progress on age discrimination. There really has. Okay. 8:37 And if you think about, um... It may not come under those words, though. The one in my, in my other book that followed with Unretirement: Purpose and a Paycheck, I tell this story about, it's a, 8:51 um, mid-size company, uh, that uses very skilled machinists. And, uh, they were talking about that they were investing in automation, senior leadership. 9:02 They're investing in automation, and the reason why they're investing in automation was not to get rid of workers, it was to keep their older skilled machinists on the payroll, to make the job easier for them so that they would stay, so they would train the younger generation. 9:17 Now, they didn't talk about age discrimination or we're making a stand against age discrimination. 9:22 What they said is, "In order to make money and in order to get the orders that we're getting, 'cause there's a lot of orders coming our way, we need to keep these people on payroll. So therefore, how do we do that? 9:33 We invest in automation." So I think with the tight labor market and the complaints that, um, so many companies and organizations have been expressing about the difficulties finding workers, that- Yeah... 9:46 the reality is there is more hiring going on. And when you look at job growth, a lot of the job growth, most of the job growth has been in the fifty-plus population. 9:55 Nonetheless, you can be sitting in a meeting and someone will say, "Ugh, I'm having a senior moment. What was that person's name?" And everybody who has been in an office has had that moment. And everybody- Yeah... 10:09 who has been in an office has had the moment when someone says, "You know, we need to, yeah, we need, we, we need to, to be faster on our technology. 10:19 Let's get some young people, uh, in a meeting together and, and, and, and let, let's let them do it." Meanwhile, if you think about your experienced worker. 10:30 So my first office job, I had an IBM Selectric, and, and [chuckles] and if you didn't hit the Enter button, you could erase a line that you had typed. You didn't have to use whiteout. 10:41 And then we went to dedicated word processors, and then we went to the PC, and now, you know, we use, uh, the laptop, we use the, you know, the tablets, we use the smartphone. We use all kinds. 10:53 If you think about the, this so-called older generation, they've li- lived through so many technological changes. They are technologically adept. Yes. 11:03 And the only thing that I think sometimes does happen is if you've been through thirty reorganizations in your company, that someone's always going, "This is the solution. 11:13 This is the solution," you might sit there and say, "Okay, I can learn this, but is this the thirtieth and we're just waiting six months for the thirty-first solution?" 11:24 So there might be a little bit of skepticism there, but that has nothing to do with not having the ability to master technology. So- Yeah... 11:32 I'm, you know, fundamentally I'm an optimist because the, the workforce is aging, the population is not growing. Yeah. 11:41 And, you know, if you wanna stay in business, uh, and I think when we're thinking about if you're in, in, in companies and organizations and you wanna think about what's gonna provide you with your competitive edge, I think it's companies that know how to hire older workers, know how to work with older workers, tap into their skill, tap into their experience. 12:02 And this isn't an either/or. And creates teams where you have younger workers, middle-aged workers, older workers working together.Drawing on their different experiences, which is good for the company. For sure. 12:15 That was everything that we should all be thinking about, um, and that companies should be thinking about in particular. Let's talk more about economics. 12:23 You've talked about the intergenerational transfer of knowledge and wealth. How do you see this playing out in today's society, especially between baby boomers and millennials? 12:35 So I think one of the, uh, biggest myths that's out there, uh, largely pushed by business consultants and ideological think tanks is this notion that there's a conflict between the generations, the intergenerational conflict, the war between the generations. 12:52 Yeah. 12:52 And, you know, it's all about scarce resources and, you know, oh, we can't afford Social Security because of all these old people, we can't afford Medicare because of all these old people, and, uh, you know, you, you know all the stories. 13:04 Yeah. 13:04 And the business consultants say, "Oh, you know, your productivity's declining because you have five generations working in this workplace, and they don't get along, and you need to hire us and we'll, we'll make, get the generations to work along." 13:17 But the thing is when you look at all the surveys, and there's been plenty of people who've done these... uh, done the work. I haven't done the work. They've done the work. 13:24 These meta surveys where you look at a survey, so they all go through the survey. What they find out is that the generations all agree. What do they want out of the workplace? 13:32 I mean, they wanna work in teams, they wanna have respect, they wanna have responsibility, they wanna be treated right. What is striking is, is how shared are the values among the generations? 13:43 But what's exciting is that, you know, I was shaped by the Vietnam War. I work with colleagues for whom the Iraq War is in the history books. Yeah. 13:53 And so we ha- we have different experiences, there are different technologies, different per- parts of the economy. So we are bringing different experiences to the table, but that's not conflict. 14:04 That's what y- that's, that's what's the basis of a conversation, but the underlying values in the workplace are the same. 14:10 So I think whenever you're thinking about society, you wanna start from an intergenerational perspective and what can the generations learn from each other, as opposed to this meme, this theme that is out there about, you know, "Okay, boomer," or- Yeah... 14:25 "Oh, you know, these millennials, they won't look me in the eye." You know, all that kind of- Yeah... but all people are doing is, you know, they're taking an anecdote here, an anecdote there. 14:34 I interviewed, um, this global design firm, and, uh, I think I'll get the, the basic story right. The, the details might be slightly off. And they've been hired by a, a company to, uh, 14:47 do all this work with their multiple generations in the organization, and it was involving technology. 14:54 And what they found fascinating was you said, you know, 40 people in a room, 40 people in a room, 40 people in a room. What they found fascinating is one person, one person complained. [laughs] Old person. 15:05 And, uh, no, everybody else was fine. Everyone got the technology, but, but what everyone remembered was the one person- Was the one person... that complained, right? And we all fall into that trap. Yeah. 15:16 So you start from intergenerational, interdependent, intergenerational equity. What can we learn from each other? How can we work together? And our values are very similar. 15:29 Our experiences are very different, and that's what... that's, that's the benefit of having a diverse workforce- Yeah... in, in multiple dimensions, right? 15:38 So, um, you know, I really push back on this notion about generational conflict. Yeah. Yeah. And I think it's, it's a, it's a sort of cynical, cheap, uh, way to be thinking about it. 15:52 I mean, I do, I do remember one time I was caddying and it was my brother and my father and, uh, they were... 15:59 My brother had graduated from business school in, in the Navy, and, uh, there were these two older guys, and they went on about how they just never hired boomers. Boomers didn't work. 16:11 [laughs] Boomers never showed up on time. You know, they complained the whole time. I actually never felt very sorry for my brother, but I actually felt sorry for him during this whole, this whole experience. 16:21 And the thing I was thinking about it, all of those stereotypes. I mean, he'd been, 16:26 he'd been working, he'd gone to business school, he'd been in the United States Navy, and all they did was just have one stereotype after another. 16:34 Now, I do think that those stereotypes are on the decline in the workplace. Yeah. They exist, they're there, but it would be wrong to say over the past 20 years there hasn't been progress. 16:48 So given your insights into the gig economy and sort of non-traditional work models, um, how do you see these trends impacting planning and saving for retirement? 17:04 So, you know, one of the things about planning and saving for retirement is, you know, one of the things to think about is do you want to work when you've left behind your primary career? Yep. 17:14 You know, is that something you want to be doing? And then do you wanna work? How much do you wanna work? I mean, some people want an encore career. Yep. 17:21 They wanna do something new, they wanna do something different, but they wanna be really absorbed by it, so they may go from the for-profit sector to the nonprofit sector, for example. 17:30 Other people are looking for part-time work. Uh, they wanna be doing other things, uh, but they wanna c- stay attached to their skills and their knowledge and a community, and they wanna be doing part-time work. 17:41 One of the advantages of the gig economy is that it's a fairly easy way to add to your work if you want to. Yeah. 17:50 I remember a, one woman that I interviewed, she was 73, I think, at the time, and she was a, uh, a driver for, uh, for Uber. Mm-hmm. And she had done a couple of other things. She'd been... 18:01 She had a, a career in the real estate industry and in the publishing industry and had done well, so she was really looking f- at work as something to do that she enjoyed.And so she tried being a receptionist, and that didn't work because you had to be there at certain hours. 18:17 She tried a couple things, and the requirements were too difficult. 18:20 And what she liked about the Uber was she turned it on when she felt like working, and she was very conversational, and so she enjoyed driving people around. It was mostly driving to the airport, that was typical. 18:32 And, uh, then she turned it off when she didn't wanna work. Mm-hmm. 18:34 And it paid for her goal, where she lived one month, uh, out of the year, uh, with her daughter, and then she also, she and three other women had their annual trip to Europe for, like, two or three weeks. 18:46 And so very low expectations, low bar. Yeah. Um, so again, it's thinking about what it is you wanna be doing. Yeah. A lot of people, you know, start their own business. 18:58 Now, that sounds like, oh, you know, twenty-four/seven, you know, starting your own business. No, I mean, you're taking your skills, your knowledge, experience. 19:05 Often, you're selling your s- your services to your previous employers. Um, again- Yep... 19:10 you make some money, you're doing something you enjoy, you probably, you know, enjoy, you know, you have skills that you accumulated over the years. 19:19 So I would be thinking through those things and build them into your plan. Yep. 19:24 And of course, we all say that, and of course then we, you know, time is, time is, is, is a precious resource, so if you don't, you take a year, you take two years, you try and figure it out. Yeah. 19:34 Uh, do some experimenting. I think the one other thing I would add is have an experimental mindset, because you are trying different things, right? Yes. And so it may not work out. That's not the end of the world. 19:46 If it doesn't work out, you learned something, you may have met some new people, you may... So you go ahead and try something different. So you may have to take several pivots or several changes along the way. 19:58 That's okay. That's what actually what happens to most. Because you think about life, that's happened a lot in life, right? Yes. That is the story of life, right, of our lives. It is. 20:06 So the fact that it happens because you're sixty or seventy, whatever, whatever it happens, eh, it's okay. 20:15 Yeah, but it's, um, such an exciting time in life 'cause you do have more agency over, presumably, over what you're choosing to do. 20:23 And whether it's gig economy or starting up something new or nonprofit or even mentoring or volunteering, all of it's accessible. 20:32 And I feel like there's gonna be even more opportunity as we go here in terms of finding things that are gonna pay you for however much money you figure you need to make on top of your savings that you've gone through. 20:45 So I think it's, um, incredibly exciting, but you're right in terms of people have to try things, and they have to be willing to, you know, give something a try and not be upset if it doesn't work out, you know, and pivot and be flexible. 20:57 So I think that's kind of a hard learning for some people if they've been in the same career the entire, like, the bulk of their career, they've been doing the same thing. 21:05 That can be challenging, but that's really, I think, the key to, um, success there. And could I just add that- Yeah, please... 21:13 um, a part of this also w- in this planning stage, you know, there's a lot of emphasis on, on retirement savings, okay? Yeah. If you have it, great. But you really also need to understand Social Security- Yeah... 21:26 and Medicare, because that's gonna be part of your plan. Once you're sixty-five, you're on Medicare, you know, your health insurance becomes easier. 21:34 Anybody who has looked at Medicare knows that Medicare itself is a maze, but it's really worth spending the time because that's your, your re- Social Security and Medicare are the foundations 21:48 of your financial plan in retirement. Yeah. And what we're talking about is you're building on top of that. And if you have retirement savings, great. 21:56 So it's your retirement savings, Social Security, Medicare, and then it's thinking about your choices and your options. And for many of us, bringing in an income does relieve a lot of financial stress. Yeah. 22:10 So you need to understand. But you need to understand. But at the same time, you know, it's true throughout life, but you've also reached that point where, I mean, and not to minimize, some people, it's just the income. 22:23 That's, they need that income. Yeah. There's just no question. Doesn't matter whether they like it, doesn't matter- Yeah. Mm-hmm... if they like the boss, they need that income. 22:29 And I don't wanna minimize that that is out there. Yeah. 22:32 But for people who have, uh, a little more flexibility, a little more choice, you wanna be doing something that you want to be doing, that you feel makes a difference. 22:41 I mean, one of the things that has struck me, I'm at the age where young college graduates will come to me and, you know, they know what a job is, but what is this thing called a career? 22:50 You know, unless you really know you wanna be a lawyer, or you really know you wanna be a doctor, you know, are you gonna go into marketing? Are you gonna go into finance? Are you gonna go... What industry? 22:59 I mean, what is this career thing? How do you think about a career? And what has struck me is... 23:04 And I, by the way, those are wonderful conversations because there's, there's idealism there, and the idealism is to be rewarded. 23:11 The idealism is I wanna do something that makes a difference, and I wanna become financially independent. Yeah. Well, if you think about your conversation with a sixty-something, it's the exact same conversation. 23:22 It's about I want to do something that, you know, I feel makes a difference. I wanna do something that helps me be financially independent. 23:30 And the only difference between the twenty-something and the sixty-something is that to the twenty-something, time is infinity. Yeah. And to the sixty-something, you're a little more aware time is short. For sure. 23:42 Um, and you have answered my next two questions. [laughs] Um, you know, I think financial literacy is, is important, and you talked about that in terms of Social Security and, um, 23:52 uh, understanding Medicare and understanding, like, truly the economics of your situation as you retire. 23:59 And then we also talked about purpose and passion, which is something that I really focus on with my clients in terms of, like, helping them find, like, what is that thing that you've, you know, that you didn't have time to explore when you were raising a family and having a career? 24:12 Like, what, what is that thing that's gonna really bring joy into your life?I'm gonna share with your clients- Yeah... you know, one of the thing is sometimes people feel the pressure to find a purpose, a calling. 24:23 And guess what? Yeah. Some people have a purpose. Some people have a calling. Many of us have multiple purposes, multiple callings, and that's fine. And they may change- Yeah... 24:34 too as you get older and as, uh, circumstances change. I mean, there may be- Yeah... a stage, for example, where the grandchildren, if you have grandchildren, really need you. 24:44 There may be a stage where the grandchildren- Yeah... don't need you as much. 24:47 Um, there may be, uh, you know, you are really engaged in your community and, and, uh, you know, getting people together and solving problems in the community, and you might reach a stage where the, you know, that's for, for somebody younger to take on because there are other things that you want to be doing. 25:05 So, you know, with this, the purpose is incredibly important. I mean, it's foundational, right? Yeah. It's just, it's not a luxury. Purpose is not a luxury. It's absolutely foundational. No. 25:16 But purpose can be m- can be multiple, and purpose can change over time. 25:21 But I do think one of the aspects of purpose is it also just simply means, you know, really thinking about what matters to you and being thoughtful about your retirement and what you do in your retirement. And- Yeah... 25:34 you know, whether, whether you use the word meaning, you use the word purpose, it's about this is an exciting stage of life. Let's take advantage of it, and that doesn't mean, um, doing, uh, 30 things in a day. 25:48 That's not taking it. That- that's not taking. But it's be- about being, you know, today was a good day, and I know why I'm getting up in the morning tomorrow. 26:01 On a personal note, did you retire and then unretire, or have you been working this entire time? I've been working the entire time. Okay. So 70 this year, and I've been working the entire time. 26:13 And I keep, you know, I interview people, and I talk to people, and I walk away and go, "Oh, that's, oh, I could do that. That is really cool. That's wonderful. I- I'd love to do that." 26:24 And about two or three days later, then I go, "You know, I really like what I'm doing." [laughs] So, you know. Yeah. I mean, the next question is, like, w- do you have plans for retirement or just keep, keep going? 26:35 Keep, do it. You know, I think it- You love what you're doing. Yeah... I think like everybody, uh, there, there is one... So I love what I'm doing. Mm-hmm. So I plan on keeping doing it. Now, 26:46 employers may, may decide we don't need your services any longer. That, that, that can happen. I can decide that I don't wanna be doing this any longer. Yes. 26:54 But I do think the only thing that I do think about, uh, in a, in, in a particularly serious level is there's some things I wanna do that require health. Yes. And, uh, you know, at some point things are gonna get harder. 27:06 And, uh, in talking to people who are friends in their, in their late 80s, you know, they've all said the same thing. 27:13 You know, there are certain things that you, that you can do in your 60s and your 70s that become harder for the average person- Yeah... in your 80s or 90s. Yeah. And, you know, think about that seriously. 27:26 And so there is, it, that's not so much retirement. That's about carving, for me, it's about carving out the time to make sure that I do those things. Doesn't require retirement. 27:37 Um, but I'm in that, you know, I'm in that lucky minority that actually really likes doing what they're doing and has no desire to stop doing it. 27:45 But I do want to be more deliberate about carving out time to do certain things that I know will be harder when I get older. What's next for you? Is there another book on the horizon? Yes, there is. 27:58 Uh, I'm kind of, I'm at the very early stages. Not sure that's gonna work out. I've gotten, I'm on my third idea, researching my third idea, but yes, there will be, there will be another, there will be another book. 28:10 Perfect. And I will certainly link to, um, your previous books and all the places where we can find you in my show notes. Chris, thank you so much for this conversation. It's been really great. Thanks a lot. 28:22 I really appreciate it. [gentle music] This podcast is sponsored by Good Morning Freedom, my retirement coaching firm. 28:30 I help executives and professionals plan the non-financial part of their retirement, like how to discover new purpose and how you want to spend your time. 28:40 I offer a one-on-one coaching retirement blueprint package where we work together to discover some new avenues of exploration for your act three. 28:49 This coaching is completely custom and we'll provide you with a ton of resources and support as you transition to this new stage of life. For all the details, please go to goodmorningfreedom.com/services. [upbeat music]